Parmenides differs from the rest of the pre-socratics previously studied (the Milesians, Xenophanes, Heraclitus and Pythagoras) in that his thought transcend the material into the abstract, asking questions about our existence and reality, essentially a start to the arena of metaphysics. Parmenides is an example of the way we should elevate our minds into the abstract. It is an invitation to live in a more contemplative way, contemplating using logic and reasoning.
Through his poem and the imagery of roads and paths, he describes our reality as having two ways the way of the Truth and the way of Opinion. The way of the Truth is the road less traveled by regular people, they go for the way of Opinion. The way of Opinion is based on the experiences that we live day to day, what we see right in front of our eyes. The way of the Truth is the one you want to be in to live well. To live in this way you have to understand the concepts of the "what is" and "what is not". The "what is" is essentially what composes the way of the Truth. Parmenides describes it as: "ungenerated and imperishable, a whole single kind, unshaken, and complete. Nor it is ever, nor will it be, since it is now, all together one, holding together." The "what is not" does not even exist because for the "what is" to be complete nothing else can be except for the "what is". Therefore, it is the way of the Truth that allows you to see everything, reality, as part of that one, complete, ungenerated Truth, in unity with it. If you are immersed in the way of Opinion you start seeing the multiplicity of reality, what you are looking at is a manifestation of the physical world, which is a deception of what the Truth really is.
Just as this philosopher influenced Plato and other philosophers, I believe that we should also let him influence us too. In fact, I must say that his ideas are necessary to help us achieve that mental exercise needed to ensure we do not take our lives for granted. The more I get to understand Parmenides the more I think about Christianity, or the nature of God. One day I was asked by my priest, who by the way is really into philosophy, "Does God exist?" I said of course He does. The priest said that it is not that He exists, He is. Now that I have read Parmenides I can say that I support the priest's view. the "it" of Parmenides is all and was not generated. By saying that God exists we are saying that He did not exists at some point. Therefore I can see how by thinking of the "it" and its characteristics can lead us to the way of the Truth.
Below Parmenides as depicted by Sanzio in "The School of Athens" looking over Pythagoras on the left.
Through his poem and the imagery of roads and paths, he describes our reality as having two ways the way of the Truth and the way of Opinion. The way of the Truth is the road less traveled by regular people, they go for the way of Opinion. The way of Opinion is based on the experiences that we live day to day, what we see right in front of our eyes. The way of the Truth is the one you want to be in to live well. To live in this way you have to understand the concepts of the "what is" and "what is not". The "what is" is essentially what composes the way of the Truth. Parmenides describes it as: "ungenerated and imperishable, a whole single kind, unshaken, and complete. Nor it is ever, nor will it be, since it is now, all together one, holding together." The "what is not" does not even exist because for the "what is" to be complete nothing else can be except for the "what is". Therefore, it is the way of the Truth that allows you to see everything, reality, as part of that one, complete, ungenerated Truth, in unity with it. If you are immersed in the way of Opinion you start seeing the multiplicity of reality, what you are looking at is a manifestation of the physical world, which is a deception of what the Truth really is.
Just as this philosopher influenced Plato and other philosophers, I believe that we should also let him influence us too. In fact, I must say that his ideas are necessary to help us achieve that mental exercise needed to ensure we do not take our lives for granted. The more I get to understand Parmenides the more I think about Christianity, or the nature of God. One day I was asked by my priest, who by the way is really into philosophy, "Does God exist?" I said of course He does. The priest said that it is not that He exists, He is. Now that I have read Parmenides I can say that I support the priest's view. the "it" of Parmenides is all and was not generated. By saying that God exists we are saying that He did not exists at some point. Therefore I can see how by thinking of the "it" and its characteristics can lead us to the way of the Truth.
Below Parmenides as depicted by Sanzio in "The School of Athens" looking over Pythagoras on the left.
You not only seem to have a really strong grasp on Parmenides, but you do an excellent job of relating Parmenides view of the One to the Judaeo -Christian view of God!
ReplyDeleteI agree. Good work.
ReplyDelete